DEBATENATE

Topics / Crime

The challenge

“Police are systemically racist”

Nate · AI character. Not a real person.

No. There are real disparities, and there are departments that earned a federal investigation. That is not the same thing as a system that's racist by design. Harvard economist Roland Fryer dug into the police data. He found Black and Hispanic civilians did face more low-level force, and in Houston's data he found no racial difference in officer-involved shootings. That's a mixed picture, and mixed means specific problems with specific fixes. When the Justice Department found unconstitutional practices in Ferguson, it forced reform. You'll say the bias hides in who gets stopped. Then go get that data and fix that practice. Let me ask you this. If policing is the enemy, why did eight in ten Black Americans tell Gallup they want police around as much or more? Every person bears God's image, citizen and officer. Name the wrong, fix it, and keep the cops.

Debate him on this

His strongest arguments

  1. Careful research finds a mixed picture: real gaps in some places, none in others. That points to specific problems, not one verdict on every officer in America.

    Roland Fryer in the Journal of Political Economy in 2019 found racial differences in lower-level uses of force but no racial differences in officer-involved shootings in the Houston data he examined.

  2. Most Black Americans want police where they live. That's hard to square with the idea that the institution is the enemy.

    Gallup's 2020 survey found eighty-one percent of Black Americans wanted police to spend the same amount of time or more time in their area.

  3. Where bias is proven, the law already works. Investigate the department, expose it, force the reform.

    The Justice Department's 2015 investigation of the Ferguson Police Department documented unconstitutional practices and evidence of racial bias, leading to a court-enforced consent decree.

The best comeback, and his answer

Challenger: Studies that start with police records miss the bias in who gets stopped in the first place, so they can make biased policing look fair.

Nate: That's an argument for better data and closer scrutiny. It isn't proof that every department in America is racist. Where the evidence shows bias, act on it hard. Where it doesn't, don't convict a whole profession.

What he grants the other side

A large study of traffic stops found Black drivers were searched on less evidence than white drivers.

The lines

Sources

  1. Fryer, R.G., Journal of Political Economy, An Empirical Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force (2019)
  2. Gallup, Black Americans Want Police to Retain Local Presence (2020)
  3. Pierson, E. et al., Nature Human Behaviour, A large-scale analysis of racial disparities in police stops across the United States (2020)
  4. U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division, Investigation of the Ferguson Police Department (2015)

More like this