DEBATENATE

Topics / America

The challenge

“America is the world's bully and should stop leading”

Nate · AI character. Not a real person.

America is no bully. But yes, it should quit trying to run the world, and those are two different things. A bully takes your lunch. After World War Two, America rebuilt the lunchroom, sending over thirteen billion dollars through the Marshall Plan, even to countries we'd just beaten. Being good doesn't mean being everybody's police force, though. We invaded Iraq over weapons stockpiles our own investigators later said weren't there. That's what a crusade costs. America First means a military so strong nobody tests it, and a rule that we don't spend American sons on regime change or write blank checks for other people's wars. You'll say if we step back, China steps up. Strength deters. Occupations drain. Let me ask you this. Which war of choice in your lifetime made your hometown better off? Be the country the world wants to copy, not the cop it has to call.

Debate him on this

His strongest arguments

  1. Bullies don't rebuild the countries they defeat. America did, and those nations became free, prosperous allies.

    The Economic Cooperation Act of 1948 created the Marshall Plan, which sent more than thirteen billion dollars to help rebuild Western Europe, including West Germany and Italy.

  2. Wars of choice and nation-building cost American lives and trust. The national interest comes first, and crusades aren't in it.

    The Iraq Survey Group's 2004 final report, led by Charles Duelfer, concluded that Iraq did not have stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction at the time of the 2003 invasion.

  3. America's alliances are chosen, not coerced. Leading by strength and example works. Policing the planet doesn't.

    NATO's Article 5 mutual defense clause has been invoked only once, after the September eleventh attacks on the United States in 2001.

The best comeback, and his answer

Challenger: America has backed coups and invaded Iraq on claims that turned out to be false. That's what bullies do, whatever the good intentions.

Nate: Iraq was a mistake, and I just said so. That's an argument against crusades, not against America. Bullies keep what they take. We rebuilt the countries we beat, and they became free allies. Keep the strength. Drop the nation-building.

The lines

Sources

  1. United States Congress, Economic Cooperation Act of 1948 (1948)
  2. United States Congress, United States Leadership Against HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria Act of 2003 (2003)
  3. NATO, Invocation of Article 5 following the September 11 attacks (2001)
  4. Central Intelligence Agency, Iraq Survey Group, Charles Duelfer, Comprehensive Report of the Special Advisor to the DCI on Iraq's WMD (2004)

More like this