DEBATENATE

Topics / Free speech

The challenge

“Safe spaces and trigger warnings help students”

Nate · AI character. Not a real person.

No. They make students more anxious, not less, and the research says so. A twenty twenty-three meta-analysis by Bridgland, Jones and Bellet found trigger warnings didn't reduce distress from the material, and they raised anxiety beforehand. Another study found they didn't help trauma survivors either. Picture a kid scared of the dog next door. Warn him about that dog every single day, and the fear grows. Let him meet the dog slowly, and the fear shrinks. That's why exposure-based therapy is a recommended treatment for P T S D. You'll say a warning is just kindness. Kindness that makes you weaker isn't kind. The only safe space a college owes you is one where every idea can be said out loud. Let me ask you this: are we preparing students for the road, or the road for students? College should make you strong, not fragile.

Debate him on this

His strongest arguments

  1. The best evidence says trigger warnings don't soften the blow. They just make people dread it more.

    A meta-analysis by Bridgland, Jones and Bellet in Clinical Psychological Science found that trigger warnings did not reduce negative emotional reactions to material and consistently increased anxiety before seeing it.

  2. Even for trauma survivors, the people warnings are supposed to help, the research found no benefit and a possible cost.

    Jones, Bellet and McNally (2020, Clinical Psychological Science) found trigger warnings did not help trauma survivors and led them to view their trauma as more central to their identity.

  3. The clinical standard for healing from trauma is facing it carefully, not avoiding it forever. Campus culture should match what actually heals.

    The American Psychological Association's 2017 Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of PTSD recommends therapies including prolonged exposure therapy and cognitive processing therapy.

The best comeback, and his answer

Challenger: Exposure therapy happens with a trained therapist at the patient's pace, not in a random lecture, so a warning just gives students control over when they face it.

Nate: Therapy is structured, sure. But the studies tested exactly this kind of heads-up, and it didn't reduce distress. Real help for trauma is a counselor and people who care about you. It is not a campus that trains every student to expect injury from an idea.

What he grants the other side

A plain heads-up before truly graphic material is ordinary courtesy.

The lines

Sources

  1. Victoria Bridgland, Payton Jones and Benjamin Bellet, Clinical Psychological Science, A Meta-Analysis of the Efficacy of Trigger Warnings, Content Warnings, and Content Notes (2023)
  2. Payton Jones, Benjamin Bellet and Richard McNally, Clinical Psychological Science, Helping or Harming? The Effect of Trigger Warnings on Individuals With Trauma Histories (2020)
  3. American Psychological Association, Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (2017)

More like this